High-quality stocks are an investor’s dream because all high-quality stocks have two things in common investors are looking for:
1. Capital gains in the long run.
2. Increasing dividends (if dividends are paid).
The reason for capital gains and growing dividends the growing profit of a company. A company growing its profits becomes more valuable, and finally, the stock price goes up. Bear markets and trends may delay this fact, but finally, the stock price will go up.
In “When cheap means crap,” I showed why the notorious price-earnings-ratio isn’t helpful in finding high-quality stocks. In contrast, it is misleading, and you may lose hard-earned money if you succumb to its false promises.
The price-earnings-ratio fails because it does not respect if profits are growing or declining. But another key metric does: Welcome to the compound annual growth rate (CAGR).
The CAGR: quantifying growth rates
The idea is to quantify the change of an underlying value (e.g. profit) in a specific period of time (e.g. five years). The result is a yearly average rate of increase or decrease in percent. Simple example:
- Company’s profit in 2015: $10 million (start value)
- Company’s profit in 2018: $15 million (end value)
- Time range: three years (period)
CAGR calculation: (15/10) ^ (1/3)-1 = 14.5 percent yearly growth rate of profit.
CAGR formula: (Start value/End value) ^ (1/ Period) – 1
The CAGR in the wild
The chart below shows the earnings history of Rollins (ROL) including the CAGR for five years from 2012 to 2017. Rollins increased profits by a yearly average of 10 percent. It becomes obvious that increase is related to the company’s quality to increase its profits. In fact: Rollins looks like a high-quality stock!
Is this the metric we are looking for? Before start cheering, let’s look at another stock. With 30 years of increasing dividends, Chevron (CVX) is a dividend aristocrat. But is Chevron a high-quality stock, too?
The CAGR for five years from 2007 to 2012 is 11.3 percent. Even higher than Rollin’s CAGR just seen. But one year later the CAGR for five years drops to -2.8 percent. What happened? In 2012, Chevron enters a period of declining profits due to a weakening oil prices. As a result, the CAGR gets worse from year to year.
The CAGR: blindness for stability
After a promising start, we found the CAGR’s weak spot. The CAGR has no clue what stable growth means. All it does is calculating the average increase between two points. What happens between these points, before and after isn’t considered at all. In the case of Chevron, rolling the CAGR to the period one year later yields a completely different result. But long-term investors need stability.
Although popular, the CAGR isn’t the solution we were hoping for. The quest for finding high-quality stocks continues.
DISCLAIMER: This article expresses my own ideas and opinions. Any information I have shared are from sources that I believe to be reliable and accurate. I did not receive any financial compensation in writing this post, nor do I own any shares in any company I’ve mentioned. I encourage any reader to do their own diligent research first before making any investment decisions.
When new travel fees fly under the radar
In the travel industry, new fees and restrictions tend to have one thing in common: they are introduced without fanfare...
What would happen if Venezuela and the Middle East couldn’t access oil?
The United States continues to pump out record amounts of oil.
Trump’s chances in the 2020 election
How will the US economy fare in the upcoming 2020 presidential elections?
What to expect from the IRS’ revised cryptocurrency guidance?
Another year, another batch of investors left in the dark.
The silver lining in pursuing foreclosed homes
Foreclosure is one real estate issue turning the buying and selling process messy.
- Business4 weeks ago
Why big data and machine learning is the future for commercial real estate
- Sponsored4 weeks ago
What the second half of 2019 holds for Bitcoin in Africa
- Crypto4 weeks ago
Using blockchain in high fashion
- Sponsored3 weeks ago
4 misconceptions retailers still have about sales analytics